Esoteric Escrows: Sorting the arcane Regulation X factor in new escrow requirements

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act authorized the transfer of rulemaking responsibility for many consumer financial protection regulations to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, including the transfer of Regulation X and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act. In December 2011, the CFPB published its renumbered regulations, and the renumbering reflects the codification of its regulations in Title 12 (Banks and Banking), Chapter X (Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection) of the Code of Federal Regulation.

Regulation X sets out the requirements for an escrow account established in connection with a federally related mortgage loan. It sets limits for escrow accounts using calculations based on monthly payments and disbursements within a calendar year. Due to the escrow rules, it is even more important to review your bank’s escrow compliance, including its understanding of escrow accounting methods, how it prepares escrow disclosure statements and determines escrow deposit amounts and how it ensures its annual escrow analysis results in correct account balances.

Three key components comprise escrow account management:

1.  Escrow analysis at creation of the escrow account. Escrow tasks must be conducted in accordance with the accounting rules outlined in Regulation X. The regulation contains rules and limitations with regard to the amounts that may be held in escrow accounts as well as specific requirements for the contents of the initial and annual statements.

Of particular note is the requirement that lenders conduct an aggregate analysis, rather than a single-item analysis, when conducting the account analysis. A single-item analysis accounts for each escrow item separately, while an aggregate analysis considers the account as a whole to compute whether escrow account funds are sufficient.

Compliance with aggregate accounting rules is necessary to accurately calculate the required escrow amounts. Creditors must ensure their mortgage staff is adequately trained on the difference between single-item and aggregate analysis and when the different analyses can or must be used. If an automated system is used to conduct escrow analysis, it must be tested to ensure it can be relied upon to perform the required calculations correctly.

Errors in the initial analysis may lead to incorrect initial escrow account statements. Errors on these statements may occur because of discrepancies between the escrow analysis and the initial escrow disclosure statement or amounts on the HUD-1 settlement statement. Some of the common errors include:

Errors in the initial analysis may cause overcharging in the collection of the initial escrow deposits.  Overcharging may result from:

2.  Charges and disbursements during the life of the escrow account. Throughout the life of an escrow account, a servicer may charge the borrower a monthly sum equal to one-twelfth of the total annual escrow payments that the servicer reasonably anticipates paying from the account. In addition, a servicer may add an amount to maintain a cushion no greater than one-sixth of the estimated total annual payments from the account. However, if a servicer determines through an escrow account analysis that there is a shortage or deficiency, the servicer may require the borrower to pay additional deposits to make up the shortage or eliminate the deficiency.

3.   Subsequent escrow account analysis and the annual escrow account statement. Errors in the annual account analysis calculations may lead to surplus, shortage, or deficiency amounts in the escrow account. Some typical causes include:

Incorrect annual escrow statements generally result from missing information, such as not including all the required elements, or from errors in the annual analysis. Examples of information that is often missing or incorrect on the annual statement include:

Reg X best practices

If your community bank offers escrow accounts, review its escrow accounting systems and disclosures to ensure compliance with the requirements of Regulation X. Lenders holding or servicing loans with escrow accounts should also consider the following best practices:

Mary Thorson  and Kris Welch are vice presidents with Chartwell Compliance.


Please wait...

Subscribe to our Technical Publication!

Want to be notified when Compass is published? Enter your email address and name below and sign up to our mailing list!
Please wait...

Download the PDF File